Fidelity Amidst Crisis

The Catholic Church, as the Mystical Body of Christ, is indefectible in her divine constitution, unchanging in her revealed doctrine, and unyielding in her sacred traditions. Yet, the Church Militant, composed of frail human members, may find herself in times of grievous crisis, when her visible leaders, through negligence or complicity, fail in their duty to guard and transmit the Deposit of Faith¹.

It is in such a time that we, the Old Roman Apostolate, find ourselves: compelled by conscience to remain steadfast in the unbroken Tradition of the Church, resisting the deleterious novelties of modernism, and continuing the sacred work of sanctifying souls through the perennial Magisterium, the immemorial liturgy, and the immutable moral law².

Rejecting Schism and Sedevacantism

We do not depart from the One, Holy, Catholic, and Apostolic Church, nor do we fashion for ourselves an alternative ecclesiastical structure³. We neither subscribe to the error of sedevacantism, which denies the visible principle of unity in the Church⁴, nor do we embrace the false spirit of accommodation, which sees no contradiction between the Catholic Faith of the ages and the deformations introduced after the Second Vatican Council⁵.

Rather, we continue in the same hierarchical and liturgical continuity that characterized the Church before the great rupture—before the dismantling of the Roman liturgy, the subversion of priestly formation, and the doctrinal ambiguities that have led so many astray⁶.

A Church in Eclipse

It would be a manifest offense against reason to deny the crisis that has beset the Catholic Church since the mid-twentieth century⁷. An honest examination of the post-conciliar period reveals:

  • A systematic suppression of the Traditional Latin Mass, which had sanctified generations and formed countless saints, replaced by a fabricated liturgy characterized by rupture and banality⁸.
  • A reorientation of ecclesial mission, no longer aimed at converting souls to the One True Faith, but at engaging in fruitless dialogues that undermine the dogma of extra Ecclesiam nulla salus⁹.
  • The collapse of catechesis, the destruction of seminaries, the weakening of religious life, and the pervasive spread of moral relativism, leaving Catholics defenseless against the spirit of the age¹⁰.
  • An unprecedented crisis of authority, in which the highest offices of the Church are wielded not to uphold the perennial teachings of Christ, but to promote theological ambiguities, equivocations, and even outright errors¹¹.

The revolution that swept through the Church in the wake of the Council was not an organic development, but a rupture—a rupture condemned by the very tradition it sought to overthrow¹².

Supplied Jurisdiction and Apostolic Continuity

Faced with the current ecclesiastical disorder, we adhere to the principle of supplied jurisdiction, a provision in Canon Law that allows for the continuation of valid sacramental ministry in times of grave necessity¹³.

Our episcopal lineage descends from the Old Roman Catholic succession, which remains recognized as valid by Rome, though modernists deem it illicit¹⁴. The charge of illicitness, however, presupposes normal conditions—conditions which, in this time of theological anarchy, no longer obtain¹⁵. As the great saints and confessors of the faith have always taught, when fidelity to Tradition and the salvation of souls are at stake, we must obey God rather than men¹⁶.

The True Faith Cannot Be Compromised

Throughout history, holy men and women have found themselves on the margins of institutional structures, not by choice, but by necessity. When Arianism gripped the episcopate, St. Athanasius remained steadfast, preserving the true doctrine even as he was unjustly exiled¹⁷. When the English hierarchy capitulated to Henry VIII, St. John Fisher stood alone, refusing to betray the faith¹⁸.

We, too, refuse to compromise the Faith. We do not deny the Petrine Office; rather, we uphold it by remaining faithful to the universal Magisterium, recognizing that obedience is owed to the fullness of Tradition, not to transient deviations¹⁹.

The post-conciliar reformation—born of liberalism and modernism, the twin errors condemned by every true pope before the Council—has led to a new ecclesiology, a new liturgy, and a new theology, all of which depart from the integral Catholic tradition²⁰. As St. Vincent of Lerins taught, true development “conserves all that has been received”; it does not introduce novelties that contradict what was always believed²¹.

Thus, we remain firmly committed to:

  • The Traditional Latin Mass, which expresses the true lex orandi of the Church.
  • The perennial teachings on faith and morals, untainted by modernist ambiguities.
  • The formation of priests, according to the authentic scholastic and Thomistic tradition.
  • The re-evangelization of souls, countering the errors of modernity and false ecumenism.

Awaiting Restoration in Hope

The Old Roman Apostolate does not seek rebellion, but restoration. We look forward, not to endless division, but to the day when the light of Tradition dispels the darkness of modernist confusion. We pray for the reconciliation of Rome with her own past, when the Eternal City will once again echo with the timeless voice of her saints and doctors.

We hold to the words of St. Athanasius²²:

“They can occupy our churches, but they are outside the true Faith. You remain outside the places of worship, but the Faith dwells within you… You are the ones who are happy, you who remain within the Church by your faith, who hold firmly to the foundations of the Faith which has come down to you from Apostolic Tradition.”

Until the Church once again embraces her full patrimony, we shall continue as faithful stewards of the mysteries of Christ—fideles dispensatores mysteriorum Dei²³.

Ad Majorem Dei Gloriam.

Footnotes

¹ Cf. Leo XIII, Satis Cognitum (1896).
² St. Pius X, Pascendi Dominici Gregis (1907).
³ St. Robert Bellarmine, De Romano Pontifice, II, 30.
⁴ Pius XII, Mystici Corporis (1943).
⁵ John XXIII, Opening Address to Vatican II (1962).
⁶ Michael Davies, Liturgical Revolution (Vol. I, 1977).
⁷ Dietrich von Hildebrand, The Devastated Vineyard (1973).
⁸ Joseph Ratzinger, The Spirit of the Liturgy (2000).
⁹ Eugène Cardinal Tisserant, Letter to Pius XII on Ecumenism (1950).
¹⁰ Pius XI, Mortalium Animos (1928).
¹¹ Cardinal Ottaviani, The Ottaviani Intervention (1969).
¹² Benedict XVI, Letter to the Bishops on Summorum Pontificum (2007).
¹³ Canon 209, 1983 Code of Canon Law.
¹⁴ Archbishop Lefebvre, Open Letter to Confused Catholics (1986).
¹⁵ St. Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae, II-II, q. 33, a. 4.
¹⁶ Acts 5:29.
¹⁷ St. Athanasius, Apologia contra Arianos.
¹⁸ E.E. Reynolds, St. John Fisher.
¹⁹ St. Vincent of Lerins, Commonitorium.
²⁰ Pius X, Pascendi Dominici Gregis.
²¹ St. Vincent of Lerins, Commonitorium.
²² St. Athanasius, Letter to His Flock.
²³ 1 Corinthians 4:1.

Leave a comment